COSMOS magazine

Get COSMOS Teacher's Notes
G Magazine
  • Add this story to Slashdot
  • Add this story to del-icio-us
  • Add this story to Digg
  • Add this story to reddit

Reviews (books, DVDs etc)

NON-FICTION

April 2007

Monkey Trial: Evolution, Creationism and Free Speech in Court

Written, produced and directed by Christine Lesiak, Co-produced and co-directed by Annie Mumgaard
Lightscape Distribution
2002
A$24.95
80 minutes
Monkey Trial: Evolution, Creationism and Free Speech in Court

The Scopes Monkey Trial in Dayton, Tennessee in 1925 is the most famous showdown so far between evolution and creationism. Rather than going into the rights and wrongs of the scientific issues, this documentary looks at the personalities and movements behind the event, using contemporary newsreel footage, photographs and newspapers, as well as the usual interviews with historians and biographers, plus relatively subtle reenactments, to help the viewer understand what it was like to be there.

The trial was actually set up by a group of ‘civic boosters’, trying to put their little town on the map, as the coal and iron mines were closing down. John Scopes, a football coach who also taught general science, agreed to their plan. He was duly arrested, but took little part in the ensuing media circus. An amazing photo shows the civic leaders and Scopes smiling together in Robinson’s Drug Store.

The battle was fought between three-time Democrat presidential nominee and devout Christian, William Jennings Bryan, and America’s most famous defence attorney, atheist Clarence Darrow. The town was besieged by more than a hundred journalists, including the famous satirist HL Mencken, and the trial was broadcast live on radio. The circus atmosphere was increased by the huge numbers of visitors to Dayton, supporters of one side or the other, and by the heat. Souvenir sellers, a trained chimpanzee named Joe Mendi and a gorilla in a cage enlivened the proceedings.


First-person

One of the most compelling ‘talking heads’ inthe documentary is Eloise Reed, who was 12 years old in 1925, and remembers Bryan fondly.