|
|
Pretty but ordinary: A remarkable close-up shot of the surface of the Sun captured by the Swedish Solar Telescope. Credit: Swedish Solar Telescope/NASA SYDNEY: The Sun has no unique properties that might have caused it to be the only star we know of that hosts a life bearing planet, say a new study. An Australian team came to that conclusion after conducting the most thorough survey ever of how the Sun compares to other stars. The research has implications for the possibility of finding life elsewhere, said the researhers led by Jose Robles from the Australian National University in Canberra. They will publish their findings in an upcoming issue of the Astrophysical Journal. Stellar characteristics It has been difficult to determine how unique Earth is in the universe since there is no data on other Earth-like planets to compare it against. Instead, astronomers have previously looked at whether there is anything significantly special about our Sun. Their research has yielded a mixed bag, however with astronomers divided on the findings. To get a better answer, Robles and his co-workers simultaneously compared 11 stellar characteristics that could plausibly influence the evolution of life. They looked at parameters such as: the Sun's mass; age; metallicity (the amount of elements heavier than helium and hydrogen, such as oxygen, carbon and nitrogen); as well as its rotation rate; its whereabouts within the galaxy; how it 'bobs up and down in the galactic plane'; and the activity of its photosphere. Using statistical methods, these were measured against data available on other stars. The analysis revealed that the Sun's most anomalous property is its mass, which is greater than 95 per cent of nearby, Sun-like stars. Its orbit is more circular than 93 per cent of these other stars and it is also older and more metal-rich than most Sun-like stars. But none of these figures were significant enough to differentiate the Sun from any other star chosen at random. Life in other solar systems "When analysing the 11 properties together, the Sun shows up as a star selected at random, rather than one selected for some life-enhancing property," Robles said. "The upshot is that there doesn't seem to be anything special about the Sun. It seems to be a random star that was blindly pulled out of the bag of all stars." The implications are that life doesn't require anything special from its host star and supports the idea that life may be common in the universe, the researchers said. Co-author Charley Lineweaver, also of ANU, said the analysis was a "simple idea with an interesting result". He said this was the most careful comparison yet done with other stars and used a lot of new data. It was also important that the research removed 'selection biases' on data, such as whether the data was taken for just bright stars. "We were expecting to find something that stood out a bit. I would have loved to have found something particular about these parameters, for example that the Sun has more uranium than other stars, but to our surprise nothing stood out," Lineweaver said. "Those who are searching for justification for their beliefs that terrestrial life and humanity in particular are special, will probably interpret this result as a humiliating dethronement," he added. Readers' comments |
COSMOS newsletter!Receive regular updates highlighting the latest in science from COSMOS. Latest News |
interesting, but...
first of all, "It has been difficult to determine how unique Earth is in the universe ..."
Please explain to your editors that "unique" is binary. Either something is or isn't unique.
Next, this research would seem to have major implications about the lifeforms on planets whose name begins with "K" and orbit a large red star.
Life DOES Need a Special Star
In 1999, astronomer Guillermo Gonzalez published an analyis in ASTRONOMY & GEOPHYSICS that concludes the sun is exceptional.
It is among most massive 10 % of stars in its neighborhood and has 50 % more heavy elements than other stars its
age and type, and about a third of variation in brightness.
The most unusual aspect of Sun isits orbit around center of Galaxy. Its orbit is significantly less elliptical than other stars its age and type, and hardly inclined at all to Galactic plane. Furthermore, Sun is orbiting very close to corotation radius for Galaxy-place at which angular speed of spiral pattern matches that of stars.
These unusual characteristics make it possible for intelligent life to emerge on Earth. Stable planetary orbits as earth's are much more likely around single stars like Sun. For massive star with inhabitable planets that are relatively far away, stellar flare-ups would be little threat to them. Heavy elements are essential to make Earth-like planets and star with stable light output is essential for life.
Circularity of Earth's orbit of Sun keeps it from plunging into inner Galaxy where life-threatening supernovae are more common. Its small inclination to Galactic plane prevents abrupt crossings of plane that would stir up Sun's Oort Cloud and bombard Earth with comets.By being near Galaxy's corotation radius, Sun avoids crossing spiral arm too often, which would expose it to supernovae which are more common there.
Because life-bearing stars have to be close to corotation radius, that rules out more than 95% of stars in Galaxy!
Nearby space could not support life
Years ago astronomer Ben Zuckerman of UCLA published a study that showed the unlikelihood of nearby stars having planetary systems where life could've evolved. This is based on the finding that the raw material needed to form "gas giant" planets like Jupiter is not available around most stars.
Gravitational pull of giant planets like Jupiter protects smaller planets like Earth from frequent collisions with comets and asteroids which would wipe out most of a species on a planet. Thus we can rule out the possibility of life in systems with no gas giants.
Zuckerman examined 20 nearby stars of about 10 million years of age to see if any are surrounded by sufficient gas to allow the formation of Jupiter-like planets. They are not.